The Decline Thesis

The Decline Thesis-67
This article was written to reflect the secondary sources.It's imperfect, of course, there are plenty of ways in which the article could be improved, but you can't contest the existence of an "Ottoman decline thesis" or claim that Ottoman decline "is a fact of history" without ignoring actual historical scholarship.Without claiming to have an extensive knowledge of the question, I think you are using a lot of argumentative strategies that are reminiscent of other elaborate contre-argumentative/apologetics strategies (such as conveying a false feeling of unity from a dissassembled set of thinkers i.e.

Tags: Custom AssignmentsSteps To Solve Math Word ProblemsPsychosynthesis Training New YorkDiscipline Essay PromptsMethods Of Critical Thinking In The Accounting ProfessionStrategic Account Business PlanBehave Classroom EssayAp Us History Dbq Essay 2005

), although you could of course discuss its causes, and I am pretty confident most specialists of International Relations would feel the same....

Quotes such as these are not hard to find in works on Ottoman history.

The empire conquered Muslim countries which previously were at the forefront of science and technology, but stopped inventing new science and technology and was late to adopt ideas coming from the west (even such monumental ideas as the printing press and clock technology).

Also, the empire, by giving the Sultan absolute power to seize anyone's property or life (a power that did not exist in Europe at the time), made Capitalism impossible and hurt the economy and the military of the empire.

Chamboz (talk) , 18 June 2018 (UTC) Chamboz, I side with Nozulani and Nyh's comments: this article seems quite one-sided.

Or, rather, it makes an elaborate argumentation in orderto disprove a theory, called the "Ottoman decline thesis", that it hereby labels as such (I don't think Bernard Lewis or any of the so-called "20th century scholars" you mentioned ever called it a thesis).

Very one-sided and subjective, sounds more like an opinion piece than an encyclopedia article.

Is the situation similar in other articles in Wiki Project Ottoman Empire? Nozulani (talk) , 26 December 2016 (UTC) I don't see how it's one-sided and subjective when it's based very thoroughly in the academic literature. Chamboz (talk) , 26 December 2016 (UTC) It's one-sided because it gives impression that the decline has been rejected by virtually all mainstream scholars, when in fact several eminent scholars have supported it at least in part, the late Halil İnalcık and Donald Quataert to name two. Donald Quataert, "Ottoman History Writing and Changing Attitudes towards the Notion of 'Decline,'" History Compass 1 (2003), 1.

Chamboz (talk) , 3 September 2018 (UTC) An editor has recently dropped a huge amount of text into this article from a different page (increasing its size by almost 30%), apparently in an attempt to merge the two articles.

Merging some sections of the articles may be a good idea, but I think the way this was done was problematic: the new text isn't integrated into the article at all and most of it doesn't even address the actual topic (the decline thesis as a historiographical concept within Ottoman history).


Comments The Decline Thesis

  • West Indian Economic Decline - Atlantic History - Oxford.

    Therefore, the decline of the British West Indian plantation system started after the Napoleonic Wars, and at a time when Britain was committed to the emancipation of slavery. Interest in the decline thesis has not dwindled and as such there have been important works that provide important surveys of the nuances in the historiography.…

  • Decline Thesis Abolitionism - Scribd

    Trade One of the most lively and long-lived historical controversies centers on the causes of. Advocates of what is commonly referred to as the "Decline Thesis" believe that slavery's faltering profitability mandated abolition, whereas the opposition tends to reject the very notion of economic hardship in the West Indies.…

  • TalkOttoman decline thesis - Wikipedia

    TalkOttoman decline thesis. It's one-sided because it gives impression that the decline has been rejected by virtually all mainstream scholars, when in fact several eminent scholars have supported it at least in part, the late Halil İnalcık and Donald Quataert to name two. You wouldn't guess that from the current edit.…

  • Ottoman Decline Thesis - YouTube

    Video Software we use https// Ad-free videos. You can support us by purchasing something through our Amazon-Url, thanks The Ottoman Decline Thesis or Ottoman Decline Paradigm.…

  • A comparison between the eric williams decline thesis and.

    Firstly there is the Eric Williams Decline Thesis found in his work Capitalism and Slavery in which he attributes the rise and decline of slavery not as an act of racial and religious control but suggests that slavery was mainly driven by economics.…

  • The Decline Thesis of British Slavery since Econocide 1986.

    The Decline Thesis of British Slavery since Econocide 1986 Abstract Appearing in 1944, Capitalism and Slavery was a comprehensive attempt to explain the rise and fall of British colonial slavery in relation to the evolution of European world-capitalism. 1 In dealing with the final stages of slavery, Eric Williams developed a two-pronged.…

  • Developing A Thesis - Harvard College Writing Center

    While cultural forces contributed to the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe, the disintegration of economies played the key role in driving its decline" is an effective thesis sentence that "telegraphs," so that the reader expects the essay to have a section about cultural forces and another about the disintegration of economies. This thesis makes a definite, arguable claim that the disintegration of economies played a more important role than cultural forces in defeating communism in.…

  • Capitalism and Slavery Reflections on the Williams Thesis.

    Capitalism and Slavery Reflections on the Williams Thesis. Part of the answer may involve a return to ideology. The material realities of trade networks, commodity markets, and labor struggles can at times prove largely out of step with how everyday people perceived these forces through thick ideological lenses.…

  • Ottoman decline thesis - Wikipedia

    The Ottoman decline thesis or Ottoman decline paradigm refers to a now-obsolete historical narrative which once played a dominant role in the study of the history of the Ottoman Empire. According to the decline thesis, following a golden age associated with the reign of Sultan Suleiman the Magnificent, the empire gradually entered into a period of all-encompassing stagnation and decline from which it was never able to recover, lasting until the empire's dissolution in 1923. This thesis was used…